Logic Diagrams as Argument Maps in Eristic Dialectics

Dialectics, Evaluation, and Argument

Dialectics and Logic Version 4

Comparing Argument Diagrams

Argumentation is central to law. Written and oral argument structures, however, are often difficult to analyze and employ in instruction. Diagrammatic models of argument offer a potential solution to these problems. In this paper we report on the results of an empirical study into the diagnostic utility of argument diagrams in a legal writing context. The focus is on comparing experts’ and stud...

Computer-assisted safety argument review - a dialectics approach

There has been increasing use of argument-based approaches in the development of safetycritical systems. Within this approach, a safety case plays a key role in the system development life cycle. The key components in a safety case are safety arguments, which are designated to demonstrate that the system is acceptably safe. Inappropriate reasoning in safety arguments could undermine a system’s ...

Using Argument Diagrams 1 Using Argument Diagrams to Improve Critical Thinking Skills in Introductory Philosophy

In an experiment involving 139 students in an introductory philosophy course we tested whether students were improving their ability to think critically about arguments and whether using argument diagramming as an analysis aid contributed to this improvement. We determined that the students did develop this skill over the course of the semester. We also determined that the students in one secti...